Automotive Software’s Next Challenge Is Procurement – And It Needs to Be Addressed Today

Munich, November 2023

Automotive Software’s Next Challenge Is Procurement – And It Needs to Be Addressed Today Munich, November 2023

T

he structured and linear procurement model of the past must give way to a new collaborative approach. 

Automakers need to adapt their procurement systematics and acquire new skills in order to source software successfully.

Earlier this year, Mercedes-Benz announced it would no longer be offering a proprietary automotive navigation and map system in favor of collaborating with Google. This signaled a significant change in the company’s software and procurement strategy. The German OEM was effectively announcing that developing, running, and maintaining core elements of its vehicle software stack required new supplier relationships in order to stay competitive with other car manufacturers – including collaboration with companies from non-automotive sectors.

Today, an estimated 73% of value creation in automotive R&D is hardware-related, but before long, the majority of value will be delivered by the software running on it. We can already identify some successful frontrunners today like Tesla and new entrants from China.

In recent years, OEMs have realized that they do not possess the in-house capabilities and resources to develop a full software stack including E/E architectures, underlying operating systems, and consumer-facing applications and services. BMW’s Senior Vice President of Electronics and Software Christoph Grote recently said: “It is completely unrealistic to build almost all software components yourself as a car manufacturer. Those who do so isolate themselves.”

However, the balance of power is also shifting. Large tech companies like Apple, Google, Tencent, and Huawei become essential contributors to software-defined vehicles. Driven by high customer expectations for the standardized integration of their platforms and services across car brands, the bargaining power of OEMs is steadily decreasing.

Consequently, OEMs needed to learn that while in the past, they were in the position to dictate a customer/supplier collaboration with Tier-1 and Tier-2 suppliers, this role may be subject to change in the era of the software-defined vehicle.

Pricing stands as the most potent lever for increasing profitability within the automotive sector. Consequently, it should take center stage for all Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs). However, it’s essential to recognize that Revenue Management extends beyond Pricing. It involves a strategic business practice adopted by companies to maximize their revenue and profitability through the optimization of product or service pricing. This discipline entails the application of diverse pricing strategies, data analysis, and forecasting techniques to make informed decisions about price setting, resource allocation, and capacity management. The primary components are depicted in the chart below. Pricing emerges as the most significant lever for enhancing profitability, making it of utmost importance for top management.

A new collaborative and flexible software procurement framework is needed

This significant role and power shift implies that OEMs will have to source key elements of their vehicle software externally while at the same time ensuring state-of-the-art integration into their vehicles in order to maintain a competitive edge. The traditional “design-bid-build” model, which is characterized by highly specified requirements, strict cost discipline, and high-volume orders, is unlikely to work in this case.

A new collaborative and flexible software procurement framework for design, development, and delivery is needed to enable co-development and partnerships. You cannot plan software development efforts years in advance. As a result, the framework must reflect the needs of the fast-moving and fast-changing nature of software projects where scope, timeline, and technology change more frequently than in classical procurement processes. This will require both internal empowerment and new evaluation criteria to assess software partners.

Figure: Software Procurement is different

Source: Berylls Strategy Advisors

In terms of internal empowerment at OEMs, we have identified four success factors:

  • Eye-level collaboration: The classic relationship between an OEM and its suppliers is a hierarchical one in which the OEM sets targets and directions and makes the important decisions. If a project goes wrong, many OEMs have specialized task force teams that will “invade” the supplier and take over operations. Due to the existing lack of software competencies at OEMs and the power of large tech providers, this approach will not work for many software projects. Software collaboration demands shared beliefs and a strategy underlying a joint approach toward the development of software products. This is why our first success factor is “eye-level collaboration.” This means that shared responsibility allows each party to contribute their unique expertise and capabilities while sharing risks related to technology, market, and regulatory compliance. Procurement must take this position on the OEM side and constantly steer this relationship with supplier management. This establishes the foundation for more flexible requirements and target setting as well as new contract and business models.

 

  • Flexible requirements and target setting: The playing field of software-defined products needs a completely different approach to target setting and documentation. Moving away from rigid specification sheets and towards flexible requirements will allow for changes and adaptations in the scope, timeline, and deliverables of the software. This approach will benefit from agile development methodologies, which emphasize iterative and incremental delivery of software and may include performance metrics that are tied to the achievement of project milestones and goals (e.g., achievement of a defined number of story points), rather than strict adherence to predefined functional requirements. Challenges arising out of this “softer” target agreement must also be addressed through new contract and business models.

 

  • New contract and business models: Traditionally, the classic contract model between an OEM and a supplier has focused on two parameters – unit price and development cost. Software was usually included in the (one-off) unit price of the hardware component. Today, however, new business models are needed for continuously developed and delivered software components. OEMs may need to evolve beyond a software license model based on production volume, irrespective of software usage intensity, and consider time-/usage-based payment models that better take into account ongoing supplier development and maintenance costs. Indeed, we predict that software-as-a-service business models will become the new normal. A further step is the participation of software suppliers in vehicle or function sales (e.g., autonomous driving functionality). This business model is applicable, especially in terms of long-term strategic partnerships and cooperation.

 

  • Software assessment competence: Procurement needs to increase its ability to understand and evaluate software and deepen its connection to hardware. This includes knowledge of the overall software architecture with all its dependencies, common programming languages, software development methods, and systematic procedures for the management of critical projects. Therefore, procurement needs to establish a close relationship to development departments in order to build up this understanding in addition to its commercial competence. This competence is crucial in order for procurement to remain a neutral partner between the supplier and the OEM development departments. It is the foundation for negotiation in the initiation phase and the basis for a successful partnership.

In addition to internal empowerment, OEMs should consider four evaluation criteria when assessing potential software partners:

  • Software delivery model: Compelling software products are the result of efficient development, rigorous testing, feedback loops, and appropriate adjustments throughout the product lifecycle. Suppliers need to offer a software delivery model that implements new requirements fast in agile teams using shorter release cycles and DevOps methods. Short feedback loops within the development value chain, from the OEM to the supplier, are a prerequisite for shortening time-to-market while maintaining quality. This enables continuous development, refinement, and delivery of software components “as-a-service” over the entire lifecycle. It stands in contrast to the traditional, SOP-focused delivery models used for hardware projects.

 

  • Software flexibility and efficiency: A modern vehicle with its increasingly centralized computer architecture processes hundreds of millions of lines of software code – it is now estimated that a typical electric vehicle uses four times as much code as a commercial jetliner. Even though computing power is continuously increasing, the complexity of porting software to multiple platforms makes the flexibility and efficiency of acquired software a strategic issue. Buyers and suppliers must move from developing static, monolithic software tailored to specific hardware to prioritizing a flexible and modular cross-domain software portfolio.

 

  • Automotive software steering competence: Nowadays, organization in agile teams to develop and maintain software is pretty much standard. But the implementation of these practices varies vastly across organizations and hierarchies. Currently, there is no global blueprint on how car software is developed and steered. The supplier’s management team in particular needs to be able to assess and handle the steering of software projects and the interfaces to the OEMs as part of automotive systems engineering. This includes efficient decision-making, prioritization, harmonization with hardware engineering, and communication in a much more volatile setup than with traditional hardware projects. And, if a project turns critical, the ability to manage overarching task forces up to and including the highest levels of corporate leadership is crucial.

Berylls Research

How to not mess up software projects
  • Processes, methods, and tools: As future automotive software will consist of both prepackaged on-board components and ad-hoc additive components, this combination will require holistic underlying processes, methods, and tools. When choosing a supplier, the consistent use of PMT across the value chain needs to be considered to ensure collaboration efficiency. One special area of focus is the requirement management process that needs to be standardized via tools and aligned processes.

The big shift

The move to software-defined vehicles is transforming the automotive procurement landscape and requires procurement professionals to adapt their practices in order to effectively source and manage software suppliers.

This means that the process and the principles of procurement must reflect the business logic of software, which is closer to signing a service contract than buying a product. To establish an innovative and future-proof software procurement organization, OEMs will need a deeper understanding of software development, supplier management, industry standards and regulations, intellectual property, and talent management. The key is self-empowerment: OEMs need to develop the necessary skillset while at the same time creating flexible and resilient organizations to manage software supplier relationships that have broken free of the “captive supplier” model and more closely resemble collaborations and joint ventures. Markdowns will not be the dominant measurement for success of procurement.

This shift will not be easy, but the software-defined automotive future demands it.

Author
Sebastian Bräuer

Associate Partner

Sebastian Bräuer
Sebastian Bräuer (1982) joined the Berylls Group in 2022 as Associate Partner. He started his career in consulting where he led and supported assignments with focus on operational excellence programs primarily in automotive but also in consumer goods and chemicals. Later Sebastian worked for an German OEM in leadership roles regarding organizational development, digital product offering and digital car strategy. At Berylls Sebastian focuses on topics regarding Digital Car.
Sebastian graduated in economics and engineering at the Technical University of Dresden.

Navigating the automotive revolution: Insights into the future of automotive operating systems

Munich, November 2023

Navigating the Automotive revolution: Insights into the fututre of automotive operating systems
Munich, November 2023

I

n the landscape of the automotive industry, an enormous transformation is underway. The very essence of vehicles is being redefined, not under the hood, but in lines of code and algorithms.

Automotive Operating Systems (AOS) have emerged as the catalysts for this revolution, promising a future where software dictates the driving experience. In our in-depth survey conducted among industry experts spanning OEMs, Tier-1 suppliers, Big Tech players, and engineering service providers, a tapestry of insights has been woven, illuminating the path forward.

Download the full study now.
Berylls Insight
Navigating the automotive revolution: Insights into the future of automotive operating systems
DOWNLOAD
Author
Dr. Jürgen Simon

Associate Partner

Sebastian Böswald

Associate Partner

Felix Günther

Consultant

Dr. Jürgen Simon

Dr. Juergen Simon (1986) is Associate Partner at Berylls Group, an international strategy consultancy specializing in the automotive industry. He is an expert in sales and corporate strategies as well as M&A and can look back on many years of consulting experience.
Dr. Juergen Simon has been advising automotive manufacturers and suppliers since 2011 and has in-depth expert knowledge in the areas of holistic strategy development, business models and commercial due diligence. He also focuses on market entry strategies and topics related to the „Software Defined Vehicle“.
Prior to joining Berylls Strategy Advisors, he worked as senior consultant at the Droege Group, a consulting and investment firm.
As a graduate economist from the University of Hohenheim, he completed his doctorate at the Institute of Management at the Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT) before joining Berylls.

Accelerating Automotive R&D: Strategies and approaches to maximize efficiency and speed

Munich, November 2023

Accelerating Automotive R&D: Strategies and approaches to maximize efficiency and speed

Munich, November 2022
A

utomotive OEMs face challenges in sustaining profitability due to escalating product complexity, which in turn results in heightened research and development expenditures.

Five improvement strategies can help not only to reduce R&D expenditures but also increase innovation cycles.

Download the full insight now.

Berylls Insight
Accelerating Automotive R&D: Strategies and approaches to maximize efficiency and speed
DOWNLOAD
Author
Sebastian Böswald

Associate Partner

Sebastian Böswald

Sebastian Böswald (1991) joined Berylls in April 2021. He is an Associate Partner and an expert in both transformation and operations. Over the last decade, he has focused his work on strategy and organizational design, as well as on two megatrends shaping the automotive industry: software-defined vehicles and CASE (connected, autonomous, shared, and electrified mobility). In these fields, he has advised our global OEM clients as well as Tier-1 suppliers and tech companies.

Prior to joining Berylls, he worked for PwC Strategy& and started his career at BMW as a project manager for product strategy and digital charging services.

He received a Bachelor of Science in Automotive Computer Science at the Technical University of Ingolstadt as well as a Master of Science in Management from the Technical University of Munich.

Semi-annual index rebalancing: WidsomTree Berylls LeanVal global automotive innovators index

Munich, October 2023

QUARTERLY INDEX REBALANCING Q3 2022

Munich, August 2022
F

ew things shape modern life as much as individual mobility. Be it as an expression of freedom and individuality, or as an economic driver. 

To reflect this, we have developed the WisdomTree Berylls LeanVal Global Automotive Innovators Index – the WTCAR. It tracks the performance of the 100 most relevant publicly listed automobility players worldwide.

By design, the WTCAR covers the industry’s entire value chain – from vehicle manufacturers and suppliers, to dealer groups, and providers of mobility services or infrastructure.

Rebalancing updates

The automotive industry experienced a severe blow from the capital markets in 2022, and the recent decline in stock prices has wiped out most of the gains that the sector had made from the pandemic lows.

Now, there are still several major effects impacting the global capital markets. First, central banks remain committed to fighting inflationary pressures and have incrementally raised interest rates as a strategic countermeasure over the past months, slowing down the recovery of the economy. Second, supply shortages caused by the Covid-19 crisis is continuously moving into the rear-view mirror, allowing for a more opti- mized production utilization. Third, political influences like the Inflation Reduction Act in the US, the war in the Ukraine, and the pressures bet- ween China and Taiwan are continuing to influence the developments at the global capital markets.

Berylls Insight
Semi-annual index rebalancing: WidsomTree Berylls LeanVal Global automotive innovators index
DOWNLOAD
Authors
Dr. Jan Burgard

Berylls Group CEO

Malte Broxtermann

Associate Partner

Björn Simon

Senior Consultant

Jakob Rüchardt

Consultant

Dr. Jan Burgard

Dr. Jan Burgard (1973) is CEO of Berylls Group, an international group of companies providing professional services to the automotive industry.

His responsibilities include accelerating the transformation of luxury and premium OEMs, with a particular focus on digitalization, big data, connectivity and artificial intelligence. Dr. Jan Burgard is also responsible for the implementation of digital products at Berylls and is a proven expert for the Chinese market.

Dr. Jan Burgard started his career at the investment bank MAN GROUP in New York. He developed a passion for the automotive industry during stopovers at an American consultancy and as manager at a German premium manufacturer. In October 2011, he became a founding partner of Berylls Strategy Advisors. The top management consultancy was the origin of today’s Group and continues to be the professional nucleus of the Group.

After studying business administration and economics, he earned his doctorate with a thesis on virtual product development in the automotive industry.

Malte Broxtermann

Malte Broxtermann (1986) joined the Berylls team in 2014. After extensive experience as emergency medical technician, he has been working in consulting since 2012. He helps customer to leverage digital strategies & products across the entire automotive value chain. He is an expert in deploying machine learning-powered applications. As Partner at Berylls’ own unit for digital solutions, Berylls Digital Ventures, he focuses on scaling start-ups as part of our venturing practice.
Studied economics and international business at Maastricht University (Netherlands) and Queen’s University (Canada).

Model Based Systems Engineering in Truck R&D

Munich, September 2023

New Premium China Survey

Munich, July 2023
T

he trucking industry is currently grappling with significant pressure induced by an ongoing transformation predicated on three fundamental changes to its long-standing operations.

Download the full insight now.

Berylls Insight
Model based systems engineering in truck R&D
DOWNLOAD
Authors
Steffen Stumpp

Associate Partner

Frederik Ruhm

Associate Partner

Steffan Lemke

Consultant

Steffen Stumpp

Steffen Stumpp (1970) joined the Berylls Group in October 2020 as Head of Business Unit Commercial Vehicles. At this point, he already looked back on extensive professional and leadership experience in the commercial vehicle industry. Stumpp started his career in an OEM and went through different roles in research, marketing, product planning and after-sales service. When he switched to the automotive supplier industry, he took over the responsibility for worldwide sales and marketing of a medium-sized tier 1 supplier. After another step as head of sales he decided to join Berylls, where he is now responsible for the commercial vehicle business.

Stumpp is a graduate engineer and has studied industrial engineering at the KIT in Karlsruhe and the Technical University of Berlin with focus on logistics.

Digital Automotive Commerce: Creating Web 3.0 experiences and strategy from business to implementation

Munich, August 2023

New Premium China Survey

Munich, July 2023
A

pple's newest Vision Pro is here and brings with it the promise of reinvigorated momentum in immersive Web 3.0 applications for OEMs.

 

As we set out in two publications last year, the Web 3.0 applications – namely in „the Metaverse“ – are high risk, uncertain reward opportunities that are not for every OEM.

Download the full insight now.

Berylls Insight
Digital Automotive Commerce: Creating Web 3.0 experiences and strategy from business to implementation
DOWNLOAD
Authors
Henry Lundt

Principal

Paul-Alexander Bures

Senior Consultant

Christian Barbuia

Senior Associate

Henry Lundt

Henry Lundt (1984) is a Principal at Berylls Mad Media (part of Berylls Group), the experts for transforming sales & marketing in the automotive industry. He is an expert in digital automotive commerce as well organizational transformation and can look back on many years of consulting experience in various roles.

Henry Lundt has been digitizing automotive sales & marketing for manufacturers and suppliers since 2009 and has experience in the areas of holistic strategy development, digital product development & applying and optimizing agile working models. Beyond this, Henry Lundt built expertise in digital automotive commerce, consulting our clients to build and optimize transaction journeys. Prior to joining Berylls Mad Media, he set up Berylls Digital Ventures as first Berylls Group entity – prior to joining Berylls, Henry Lundt was Head of Automotive at TD Reply, a marketing & innovation consulting firm, focused on digital business.

He graduated as business economist from the University of EBC Berlin in marketing & media with a combined studies in Business Management in University of Sunderland & University of Newcastle upon Tyne (UK).